Faceless Penalty Proceedings under Section 270A & Section 271AAB: Legal Defences & Immunity Applications under 270AA

Published: December 28, 20246 min readEffective: Applicable across all ongoing penalty proceedings

View Official Gazette / Govt Source Consult Senior Partner

Executive Regulatory Summary

A strategic litigation guide on responding to faceless penalty show-cause notices for under-reporting (50%) and misreporting (200%) of income under Section 270A. Explores the statutory statutory immunity mechanism under Section 270AA to eliminate penalties and halt prosecution.

Key Statutory Takeaways

Under-reporting of income attracts penalty of 50% of tax payable; misreporting attracts 200% penalty.
Bona fide explanations with documented books of accounts cannot be treated as under-reported income under Section 270A(6).
Immunity application in Form 68 under Section 270AA must be filed within one month of receiving assessment order.
Immunity is conditional upon payment of tax and interest determined in the assessment order without preferring an appeal.

Actionable Compliance Checklist for Businesses

Step-by-step advisory measures prescribed by ASGR and CO for immediate adherence:

1Review assessment order to ascertain whether additions are classified as 'under-reporting' or 'misreporting'.

2If additions are based on debatable legal issues and no appeal is warranted, pay tax and submit Form 68 for statutory immunity.

3If additions are contested, file appeal before CIT(A) within 30 days and file an adjournment letter in penalty proceedings.

4Submit paginated, evidentiary written submissions on the faceless portal demonstrating bona fide conduct.

1. Understanding the Distinction Between Under-Reporting and Misreporting

Section 270A revolutionized the penalty framework by replacing subjective 'concealment' with objective criteria. However, Assessing Officers frequently levy 200% misreporting penalties mechanically without proving deliberate falsification of books.

Target Entities Governed by this Notification:

Taxpayers Subject to Scrutiny AdditionsCorporate Legal CounselsTax Litigation AdvocatesChartered Accountants

Advisory Published By

CA Nitin Singrodia

Partner - Direct Tax & Litigation • B. Com, FCA, DISA (ICAI)

ASGR and CO, Chartered Accountants (Peer Review Certified: #018Xxx)

Statutory Disclaimer: This publication is compiled by ASGR and CO solely for general informational and educational purposes to assist corporate clients and peers in understanding statutory notifications. It does not constitute legal, tax, or formal secretarial advice. Before acting upon any provisions, specific professional counsel should be sought.

Official Statutory Link